The Role of New Evidence in Post-Conviction Appeals: How It Can Change Your Case

The Role of New Evidence in Post-Conviction Appeals: How It Can Change Your Case

Back to Blog

When someone is convicted of a serious crime, the verdict is not always the end of the story. Sometimes, new evidence can emerge that has the power to change the outcome of the case. For individuals who have been wrongfully convicted or given an excessively harsh sentence, this new evidence can offer a lifeline for justice. Post-conviction appeals, particularly those that present new evidence, are a powerful tool in ensuring that individuals receive the fair treatment they deserve. At Conviction Solutions, led by seasoned attorney Jamie Resch, we have great experience  in using new evidence to challenge wrongful convictions and appeal unjust sentences.

Understanding Post-Conviction Appeals

Post-conviction appeals are legal processes that allow individuals to challenge their conviction or sentence after the original trial has concluded. These appeals are often based on procedural errors, legal mistakes, or new evidence that wasn’t available during the trial. For those facing felony charges, violent crime convictions, or even death row sentences, post-conviction appeals can be a crucial opportunity to correct an injustice.

At Conviction Solutions, we take a comprehensive approach to each post-conviction appeal, meticulously reviewing the original trial for any mistakes and uncovering new evidence that could make all the difference in the case.

What Qualifies as New Evidence?

New evidence is any information that was not presented during the original trial and that could significantly affect the outcome of the case. This could be because the evidence was unknown, unavailable, or improperly excluded during the trial. Here are a few examples of new evidence that often play a key role in post-conviction appeals:

  • DNA Evidence: Advancements in forensic science, particularly DNA testing, have led to the exoneration of many wrongfully convicted individuals. If DNA evidence was not available or not properly tested during the trial, it can be presented during a post-conviction appeal to challenge the conviction.
  • Witness Testimony: Sometimes, witnesses come forward after the trial with new testimony that sheds light on critical facts that were either misunderstood or overlooked. Alternatively, witnesses who testified during the original trial may recant their testimony, which can cast doubt on the conviction.
  • New Expert Analysis: In some cases, expert witnesses may provide new scientific, medical, or forensic insights that were unavailable during the trial. This could include updated ballistics reports, medical evaluations, or psychological assessments.
  • Confessions or Admissions: If another individual confesses to the crime or if new evidence points to someone else as the perpetrator, this can be presented as new evidence to overturn the conviction.

How New Evidence Can Change Your Case

The introduction of new evidence in a post-conviction appeal can drastically alter the trajectory of a case. Here’s how new evidence can impact the outcome:

1. Overturning a Conviction

In many cases, new evidence can lead to the complete exoneration of a convicted individual. For example, DNA evidence that proves the defendant did not commit the crime, or a new witness who testifies that the defendant was not present at the scene, can result in the court overturning the original conviction.

2. Securing a Retrial

If the new evidence is compelling but not conclusive enough to overturn the conviction outright, the court may grant the defendant a retrial. This gives the defense team the opportunity to present the new evidence alongside the rest of the case, allowing for a fresh evaluation by a new jury.

3. Reducing Sentences

In some cases, new evidence may not completely exonerate the individual, but it can lead to a reduction in the severity of the sentence. For example, if new medical evidence shows that the defendant’s actions were influenced by a mental health condition that was not properly considered during the trial, the court may reduce the sentence accordingly.

The Conviction Solutions Approach: How We Use New Evidence to Build a Strong Appeal

At Conviction Solutions, we are experts at uncovering and leveraging new evidence to build a strong post-conviction appeal. With over two decades of legal experience, attorney Jamie Resch and his team meticulously review each case, looking for any signs of legal errors or missing evidence that could change the outcome.

Here’s how we help our clients:

1. Comprehensive Case Review

The first step in any post-conviction appeal is a thorough review of the original case. Conviction Solutions examines every detail—from trial transcripts to witness testimonies and forensic evidence—to identify any oversights or mistakes that may have occurred during the trial. This careful analysis often reveals opportunities to introduce new evidence that can support an appeal.

2. Gathering New Evidence

Once we’ve reviewed the case, we work closely with forensic experts, investigators, and medical professionals to gather new evidence. Whether it’s DNA testing, new witness statements, or expert analysis, our goal is to present the strongest possible case for our clients.

3. Presenting the Appeal

With new evidence in hand, we prepare a compelling appeal to present in court. Jamie Resch has successfully argued cases before the Nevada Supreme Court, United States District Court, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, and even the United States Supreme Court. His experience in these high-level courts ensures that every appeal is presented with precision and expertise.

Success Stories: How Conviction Solutions Has Changed Lives with New Evidence

At Conviction Solutions, we have a proven track record of success in post-conviction appeals, including cases where new evidence has completely transformed the outcome. For example, we’ve helped clients serving long prison sentences present new medical or forensic evidence that was previously unavailable, leading to favorable results in their appeals.

One of our most notable successes involved a client who had been convicted of a serious crime but was later exonerated due to evidence which went unused at the time of trial. This evidence, which was ignored during the original trial, led to the court overturning the conviction and freeing our client.

Conclusion: Why New Evidence Matters in Your Post-Conviction Appeal

If you or a loved one has been convicted of a serious crime, new evidence could be the key to changing the outcome of the case. Whether it’s DNA testing, witness testimony, or expert analysis, presenting new evidence can lead to a retrial, reduced sentence, or even complete exoneration.

At Conviction Solutions, we are dedicated to ensuring that justice is served. If you believe new evidence could impact your case, contact us today. Our experienced team, led by attorney Jamie Resch, is here to help you navigate the complex appeals process and fight for your rights.

Contact Conviction Solutions to schedule a consultation and explore how new evidence can make a difference in your post-conviction appeal.

Copyright © 2024 ConvictionSolutions.com. Site by Hunter Marketing